Cost Optimization Strategies in Product Engineering

In the highly competitive landscape of modern manufacturing, product engineering cost optimization has become a pivotal strategy for companies aiming to maintain profitability, enhance customer satisfaction, and stay ahead of the competition. The engineering phase, where up to 80% of the product's cost is determined, is a crucial period for implementing cost-reduction initiatives. Here, we will explore the key strategies, methodologies, and tools that can help in optimizing product costs effectively.

The Importance of Early Design Considerations

One of the most significant insights in product engineering cost optimization is the realization that the majority of a product's cost is locked in during the design phase. This is because the type of manufacturing process, material selection, and geometric design of parts are decided early on, influencing the overall cost structure of the product.

To address this, manufacturers are adopting a "shift left" mindset, where cost, manufacturability, sustainability, and risk are considered early in the product development process. This approach involves integrating cross-functional teams, including design engineers, cost engineers, procurement, sustainability, and manufacturing operations, to identify and mitigate potential issues before they become costly problems.

Material Cost and Process Optimization

Material costs play a critical role in high-volume production, especially in additive manufacturing processes. For instance, in high-volume additive processes, material costs can overshadow tooling and process costs. However, for subtractive processes like milling and turning, the focus shifts to process costs, particularly when working with standard materials like steel or stainless steel. For more exotic materials such as titanium, material costs can be significantly higher and must be carefully managed.

Tolerance is another often-neglected area in design that can significantly impact manufacturing costs. Tight tolerances may be easy to specify in the design phase but can become a manufacturing nightmare, requiring additional secondary finishing processes. Early cost estimation and Design For Manufacturability (DFM) reviews can help design engineers understand the cost implications of their design choices and make necessary adjustments to avoid costly downstream processes.

Holistic Product Optimization

Effective product cost optimization requires a holistic approach that considers multiple perspectives: market, value, and cost. This involves understanding market dynamics and customer preferences to position the product optimally, balancing cost-effective engineering parameters with requirements management, and conducting a cross-functional analysis of all efficiency potential across the entire value chain.

Roland Berger's four-step project approach is a comprehensive example of this holistic methodology. It includes product scoping and planning, defining the sweet spot through market and value analyses, validating ideas through detailed benchmarking, and implementing measures with clear ownership and timelines. This approach has been shown to deliver significant cost savings and revenue increases.

Advanced Technological Tools and Methodologies

Traditional cost reduction methods often rely on tribal knowledge and manual calculations, which can be inefficient and inaccurate. Modern product cost optimization (PCO) strategies leverage advanced technologies such as automation, data analytics frameworks, and powerful computing infrastructure to generate accurate cost estimates in near-real time.

Tools like computer-aided design (CAD) extractors, parts communization, and template-based algorithms help engineers estimate design iteration costs, improve cost and product reliability, and create agile cost models. These tools enable the rapid evaluation of multiple engineering alternatives from a cost perspective without the need for physical prototypes.

Next-Generation Cost-Down Approaches

Next-generation product cost-down approaches take a multidimensional view of cost, examining its sources and addressing underlying non-optimized elements of the operating model and organization. This involves identifying and addressing root causes rather than just symptoms, using agile methods to ensure holistic coverage of the product, and involving customers and suppliers in the cost-reduction efforts.

For example, an international plant-engineering firm identified an excessive safety buffer in one of their electric motors by tracing the issue back to an outdated performance guideline. By addressing this root cause, the company was able to sustainably reduce costs across the entire product series.

Balancing Cost Reduction and Customer Value

Product cost optimization is not just about cutting costs; it is about finding the sweet spot where the product's cost aligns with the value proposition that customers are willing to pay for. This balance is crucial for maintaining customer satisfaction and market positioning.

Companies need to redesign products to focus on features highly valued by customers while removing unnecessary complexity and rarely used functionality. This approach can result in substantial cost reductions without compromising customer perceptions of the product's value.

Implementation and Sustainability

Implementing cost optimization strategies requires a structured approach. This includes product scoping, defining the sweet spot, validating ideas, and implementing measures with clear ownership and timelines. It is also essential to integrate these methodologies into the organization's cost management approach to ensure sustainability.

Quick wins that result in rapid profitability improvements should be combined with longer-term measures to create compelling success stories. Involving customers and suppliers in the process can also lead to win-win opportunities for all stakeholders.

Conclusion

Product engineering cost optimization is a multifaceted challenge that requires a combination of early design considerations, holistic approaches, and advanced technological tools. By adopting a "shift left" mindset, optimizing material and process costs, using holistic product optimization strategies, and leveraging next-generation cost-down approaches, companies can achieve significant cost reductions without compromising product value.

To streamline your product engineering process and optimize costs effectively, consider leveraging AI-driven tools. Sign up to Scopebird, a cutting-edge SaaS platform designed to help you scope out your next technical product instantly. With Scopebird, you can automate cost and DFM guidance, simulate multiple design scenarios, and evaluate trade-offs to determine the most effective path forward.